Administrator
|
On October 13, torch369 <[hidden email]> wrote:
> I thought negative ion generators clean the air, like what happens after > a rainstorm. As long as it doesn't produce ozone. > Steve In my experience, ion generators do nothing about odors and VOCs. You need ozone for that. However, ion generators (even the kind without fans) caused a "prickly" ES sensation on my skin, so I abandoned using them altogether (plus they blackened my walls and furniture). I have no problem with ozone in small amounts (the same amounts found outdoors). Marc |
In reply to this post by Auntie Patricia
*Dirty power* is known as dirty frequencies in the mains electricity net.
*Dirty air* are dirty frequencies floating in the air. Between 5kHz and as high as 30MHz! They are transmitted by electrical appliances, wall sockets, and even are present in grounding cables. I measure them in the ground! That is the reason why some electrosensitives do feel worse after they have applied shielding paint. Because thiss paint must be grounded, but the grounding cable just picks up these frequencies. Greetings, Charles Claessens member Verband Baubiologie www.milieuziektes.nl www.milieuziektes.be www.hetbitje.nl checked by Emsisoft ----- Original Message ----- From: Auntie Patricia To: [hidden email] Sent: Saturday, October 13, 2012 9:15 AM Subject: Re: [eSens] negative ion generators are not all equal what do you mean by 'dirty air', charles? 'dirty air' to me is chemtrails and mold and smoke and perfumes, etc. i find that my air is far cleaner with NIGs. when they are accidentally turned off, the building odors are noticeable. when they are turned on, the air is clean and clear. visitors comment on how clean the air is. have you lived with ALL negative ion generators? have you seen a demo with smoke in the air? and so on and so forth. what is your actual experience with them? and what is your business? as i said before, there are no moving parts in mine and it does not put out measurable EMF... but a NIG with a fan might put out EMF - and i have measured them doing so. patricia On Oct 12, 2012, at 11:56 PM, charles wrote: > ALL negative ion generators do produce what I call *dirty air*. > > So they should be avoided. > > Greetings, > Charles Claessens > member Verband Baubiologie > www.milieuziektes.nl > www.milieuziektes.be > www.hetbitje.nl > checked by Emsisoft > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: Auntie Patricia > To: [hidden email] > Sent: Friday, October 12, 2012 9:24 PM > Subject: [eSens] negative ion generators are not all equal > > > puk, thanks for the info and for helping me > clarify something for myself... > > does yours have a fan? > i have some with fans and one without. > the ones with fan DO measure high in EMF... > the one without a fan measures the same > as the ambient room EMF, no matter where > i hold my EMF meter. > > this is the one i have ... > http://www.negativeiongenerators.com/roomionizers.html > hmm... i think the price has not changed > since i bought mine ten years ago. > i put this in the center of my home and > it works well. i think i'll get rid of the > others, now that i am clear that fans > are not good to mix with EMF. > > thanks. > patricia > > > On Oct 12, 2012, at 3:53 AM, [hidden email] wrote: > >> I find that the mains powered air purifiers can give off high levels of EMR >> and dirty power so they negate the clean air benefit for me, unless you >> can get a whole house system where the fan unit and electronics are well away >> from the inhabited parts of the house and even then the unit should be >> filtered for dirty power influx to your mains wiring >> >> puk > > > ------------------------------------ > > Yahoo! Groups Links > > > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Yahoo! Groups Links > > > > ------------------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Links [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] |
Administrator
|
In reply to this post by Marc Martin
On October 13, Marc Martin <[hidden email]> wrote:
> In my experience, ion generators do nothing about odors > and VOCs. You need ozone for that. I guess I should clarify that... most negative ion generators create 2 things: -- negative ions (as advertised) -- ozone (byproduct) The negative ions cause airborne particles to fall out of the air. The ozone destroys odors, VOCs, and creates a "fresh air" smell. Meanwhile, everyone demonizes ozone as some terrible, toxic thing, when in fact when you go outside and smell "fresh air", what you area really smelling is ozone. Consumer ozone generators can cause people problems when the amounts of ozone they generate is far beyond what is found in nature, and also when there are non-ozone byproducts (e.g, nitric oxide). Marc |
In reply to this post by Amanda Kolter
Thanks Charles, that's probably really good advice in a dry climate.
However I want to point out that in Seattle or anywhere damp, that sounds like a mold problem waiting to happen. Which can definitely affect the immune system and everything, and make ES symptoms worse. Amanda Re: carpet<http://groups.yahoo.com/group/eSens/message/28059;_ylc=X3oDMTJzc2w2ZTI4BF9TAzk3MzU5NzE1BGdycElkAzExOTc5MzA0BGdycHNwSWQDMTcwNTA2MjIxNQRtc2dJZAMyODA1OQRzZWMDZG1zZwRzbGsDdm1zZwRzdGltZQMxMzUwMTM5MTQ1> Fri Oct 12, 2012 11:59 pm (PDT) . Posted by: "charles" bitje2005<[hidden email]?subject=Re%3A%20carpet> Carpets may also belong to the big family of elektrosmog. They may contain static CD electrical fields. Sometimes it may help when a bit moisture is added. Greetings, Charles Claessens member Verband Baubiologie www.milieuziektes.**nl www.milieuziektes.**be www.hetbitje.**nl checked by Emsisoft [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] |
In reply to this post by PUK
yes, it is the metal against metal that makes fans emit
high EMF. i was experimenting yesterday in my car. each time i hit the brakes, the meter beeped. the fan for my computer is in the bottom of the screen... also the hard drive that whirrrs. that's where the high emf also resides... motion + metal = problem. the NIG that has no moving parts is different, apparently. i'll use that one and only that one, now that i am clear on the concept. :) patricia On Oct 13, 2012, at 3:12 AM, [hidden email] wrote: > i wouldn't be surprised if fans literally throw off electrons just as they > disperse air |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin
i wonder if if is the prickly feeling was due to the
particles being zapped out of the air? i used to live on a street in san francisco that a bus drove down several times a day. i liked to keep my window open because MOST of the time i could hear the ocean and watch the waves come in and only a LITTLE bit of the time, the bus came by. my wall was BLACK behind the leg of the table where my NIG sat on the floor... so i agree that a non-motor NIG will do that. i was grateful to it for saving my lungs from the black that went on the wall. maybe we're talking 'glass half full' and 'glass half empty' at each other. :) i prefer to have the particles zapped out of the air. and i don't personally feel prickly. ? On Oct 13, 2012, at 7:49 AM, Marc Martin wrote: > On October 13, torch369 <[hidden email]> wrote: >> I thought negative ion generators clean the air, like what happens after >> a rainstorm. As long as it doesn't produce ozone. >> Steve > > In my experience, ion generators do nothing about odors > and VOCs. You need ozone for that. > > However, ion generators (even the kind without fans) > caused a "prickly" ES sensation on my skin, so I > abandoned using them altogether (plus they blackened > my walls and furniture). I have no problem with ozone > in small amounts (the same amounts found outdoors). > > Marc > > > ------------------------------------ > > Yahoo! Groups Links > > > > |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin
good distinction, marc.
ozone is one thing... negative ions are another. i use an ozonator at my home too. it emits a GREAT DEAL of EMF. but it purifies my drinking water and i appreciate that. i do not smell ozone around my NIG that has no moving parts... but i do around a NIG that has a fan. and i feel 'prickly' around it. it stings my nose and eyes. so i don't run it when i am in the room. and what i am figuring is that the negative ions ZAP (somehow throw to the earth) particulate matter - which also may be perceived as odor because you smell things that are lingering in the air... i saw a demo once - a glass dome was filled with cigarette smoke. the NIG button was pushed and the smoke fell to the ground. i used NIGs when i had new carpet put in my home. took a day or two and then everything was fine. of course, i wasn't living there, just preparing the place, so i could run the NIGs all day long. they were from 'the sharper image' - two tall towers. whither i go, my NIG goes with me... and now i know only to ever buy ones that have no fans. :) thanks to this list. :) so yes, absolutely, you don't want to LIVE near a NIG... you want it to do its work apart from your immediate living area. i had the 'no-fan' NIG on the bannister above my living room, kitchen, dining area, and it covered that area, plus the top floor where my office, bedroom and bathroom were. i had another NIG (with fan) in the living room, and i turned it off when i had company. i also closed the doors of my bedroom at night with no NIG in it. i guess it takes a bit of getting used to... where to put them, when to use them. i've been happily using them for about 35 years. my first had no fan. it was a very good friend. patricia On Oct 13, 2012, at 8:02 AM, Marc Martin wrote: > On October 13, Marc Martin <[hidden email]> wrote: >> In my experience, ion generators do nothing about odors >> and VOCs. You need ozone for that. > > I guess I should clarify that... most negative ion > generators create 2 things: > > -- negative ions (as advertised) > -- ozone (byproduct) > > The negative ions cause airborne particles to fall out > of the air. The ozone destroys odors, VOCs, and creates > a "fresh air" smell. > > Meanwhile, everyone demonizes ozone as some terrible, > toxic thing, when in fact when you go outside and > smell "fresh air", what you area really smelling is > ozone. Consumer ozone generators can cause people > problems when the amounts of ozone they generate is far > beyond what is found in nature, and also when there > are non-ozone byproducts (e.g, nitric oxide). > > Marc > > > ------------------------------------ > > Yahoo! Groups Links > > > > |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin
I've seen that happen before also with the walls but the one mentioned in that link comes with a dust grabber built in and they say it shouldn't be a problem. There are also different types of generators. That site has a money back guarantee so I may try it.
They also have something call Air Oasis which is more for odors and VOCs and it has photocatalytic plus ion. It gives off a little ozone but they say the levels are safe. I'm very sensitivie though so I would only run it when I'm not there if I decided to try it as well. I have a Blueair air purifier right now which does use ionizers but no ozone. It's made of metal which is good for my MCS but the filters absolutely stink, which kind of negates the MCS properties. It doesn't seem to clean out much dust either. Looking for a replacement. Steve --- In [hidden email], Marc Martin <marc@...> wrote: > > On October 13, torch369 <torch369@...> wrote: > > I thought negative ion generators clean the air, like what happens after > > a rainstorm. As long as it doesn't produce ozone. > > Steve > > In my experience, ion generators do nothing about odors > and VOCs. You need ozone for that. > > However, ion generators (even the kind without fans) > caused a "prickly" ES sensation on my skin, so I > abandoned using them altogether (plus they blackened > my walls and furniture). I have no problem with ozone > in small amounts (the same amounts found outdoors). > > Marc > |
Marc, You said: However, ion generators (even the kind without fans) > caused a "prickly" ES sensation on my skin, so I > abandoned using them altogether (plus they blackened > my walls and furniture). Why/how did the ion generators blacken the walls? Lizzie > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] |
Administrator
|
On October 14, Elizabeth thode <[hidden email]> wrote:
> Marc, You said: > > However, ion generators (even the kind without fans) > > caused a "prickly" ES sensation on my skin, so I > > abandoned using them altogether (plus they blackened > > my walls and furniture). > > Why/how did the ion generators blacken the walls? Lizzie All those particles that the negative ion generators remove from the air have to go somewhere -- unfortunately, they usually end up on a wall or a couch that's next to the generator. And that stuff's seemingly impossible to remove (we eventually through away the couch, repainted the walls, and banned negative ion generators from the house). Marc |
Who would have thought....Thanks, very insightful. Lizzie To: [hidden email] From: [hidden email] Date: Sun, 14 Oct 2012 12:30:47 -0700 Subject: Re: [eSens] Re: negative ion generators are not all equal On October 14, Elizabeth thode <[hidden email]> wrote: > Marc, You said: > > However, ion generators (even the kind without fans) > > caused a "prickly" ES sensation on my skin, so I > > abandoned using them altogether (plus they blackened > > my walls and furniture). > > Why/how did the ion generators blacken the walls? Lizzie All those particles that the negative ion generators remove from the air have to go somewhere -- unfortunately, they usually end up on a wall or a couch that's next to the generator. And that stuff's seemingly impossible to remove (we eventually through away the couch, repainted the walls, and banned negative ion generators from the house). Marc [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] |
My experience has been the same as Marc's on a stand-alone Neg.ion generator that I once owned. It made the adjoining wall blackened as if I had been burning a campfire inside the house next to it.. Also, I do currently own 2 different Hepa filter machines which have a neg. ion generator built in and have not experienced any blackened walls. I'm not really sure if I'm getting any benefit from them; they are incidental to the filter unit. One thing that I have had success with in oxidizing different VOC's, toxins, etc. related to new construction is by using a heavy-duty OZONE machine BEFORE we moved in. The machine I use (by Air Zone) has a timer on it so that I am not exposed to the Ozone and can give it adequate time to dissipate. I ran my ozone unit many times in various parts of the house and it was very effective in reducing the level of odor. One strategy is putting it next to the return air and running the HVAC fan to circulate the ozone(while you and your animals are NOT there). Of course, it's best to use non-toxic construction materials in the first place when possible since this is not a perfect solution. Jim --- In [hidden email], Elizabeth thode <lizt777@...> wrote: > > > Who would have thought....Thanks, very insightful. Lizzie > To: [hidden email] > From: marc@... > Date: Sun, 14 Oct 2012 12:30:47 -0700 > Subject: Re: [eSens] Re: negative ion generators are not all equal > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > On October 14, Elizabeth thode <lizt777@...> wrote: > > > Marc, You said: > > > > However, ion generators (even the kind without fans) > > > > caused a "prickly" ES sensation on my skin, so I > > > > abandoned using them altogether (plus they blackened > > > > my walls and furniture). > > > > > > Why/how did the ion generators blacken the walls? Lizzie > > > > All those particles that the negative ion generators remove > > from the air have to go somewhere -- unfortunately, they > > usually end up on a wall or a couch that's next to the > > generator. And that stuff's seemingly impossible to > > remove (we eventually through away the couch, repainted > > the walls, and banned negative ion generators from the > > house). > > > > Marc > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] > |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin
marc, they now have negative ion generators
with collection plates so they do not throw black stuff on the wall. the one i linked to has that feature. interestingly, i just read the list of attributes and it mentions EMF at the bottom: • Superior quality, long-lasting, highly effective, reliable, genuine negative room ionizers. Generates an optimum level of high-density negative ions. • Very effectively removes particles from the air as small as .01 microns, such as pollen, dust, mold spores, pet dander, and other allergens. • Negative ion output 80 to 100 trillion ions per second, externally. (That is, out into your room, instead of being captured and trapped inside the ionizer). • For large or small rooms - covers 4000 cubic feet (a 20' W x 20' L x 10' H room). • Ionization method requires no filter, so there's never a need to buy or clean filters. • Neither are noisy fans or blowers required. Room air is cleaned and purified noiselessly- completely silent. • More effective than expensive HEPA filters or electronic air cleaners: ionized room air does not have to be circulated by a fan and pass through a filter to be cleaned. • Uses no chemicals, perfumes, filters, or agents. • Does not produce harmful EMF (electromagnetic fields). On Oct 14, 2012, at 12:30 PM, Marc Martin wrote: > On October 14, Elizabeth thode <[hidden email]> wrote: >> Marc, You said: >>> However, ion generators (even the kind without fans) >>> caused a "prickly" ES sensation on my skin, so I >>> abandoned using them altogether (plus they blackened >>> my walls and furniture). >> >> Why/how did the ion generators blacken the walls? Lizzie > > All those particles that the negative ion generators remove > from the air have to go somewhere -- unfortunately, they > usually end up on a wall or a couch that's next to the > generator. And that stuff's seemingly impossible to > remove (we eventually through away the couch, repainted > the walls, and banned negative ion generators from the > house). > > Marc > > > ------------------------------------ > > Yahoo! Groups Links > > > > ------------------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/eSens/ <*> Your email settings: Individual Email | Traditional <*> To change settings online go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/eSens/join (Yahoo! ID required) <*> To change settings via email: [hidden email] [hidden email] <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [hidden email] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ |
In reply to this post by PUK
Paul
I have one of those in the loft in my house - I had no idea it had anything to do with negative ions - I turned it off because it just made the house really cold and hard to heat Steph ________________________________ From: "[hidden email]" <[hidden email]> To: [hidden email] Sent: Saturday, 13 October 2012, 11:12 Subject: Re: [eSens] negative ion generators are not all equal i wouldn't be surprised if fans literally throw off electrons just as they disperse air, that said some air movers and Aircon units have lots of electronics and this definitely makes this potential phenomenon worse. My local superstore has a fan unit in the ceiling which I try to avoid staying under as it causes the bridge of my nose and scalp to sting. My daughter had a battery operated hand held fan which had led lights built into the blades of the fan, when I put this near the digital TV, the picture broke up, so evan battery fans can have an effect. I also have a pifco air humidifier which has no fan but this gives of mad levels of emf, so I have long dispensed with using these devices - a whole house positive pressure system is best where the fan unit is high up in a loft space and the air it draws in from the outside is filtered and is passed to internal vents which then leads to posite presurisation of the house nad a good deal of air changes per hour... puk In a message dated 13/10/2012 07:55:50 GMT Daylight Time, [hidden email] writes: ALL negative ion generators do produce what I call *dirty air*. So they should be avoided. Greetings, Charles Claessens member Verband Baubiologie www.milieuziektes.nl www.milieuziektes.be www.hetbitje.nl checked by Emsisoft ----- Original Message ----- From: Auntie Patricia To: _eSens@yahoogroups.com_ (mailto:[hidden email]) Sent: Friday, October 12, 2012 9:24 PM Subject: [eSens] negative ion generators are not all equal puk, thanks for the info and for helping me clarify something for myself... does yours have a fan? i have some with fans and one without. the ones with fan DO measure high in EMF... the one without a fan measures the same as the ambient room EMF, no matter where i hold my EMF meter. this is the one i have ... _http://www.negativeiongenerators.com/roomionizers.html_ (http://www.negativeiongenerators.com/roomionizers.html) hmm... i think the price has not changed since i bought mine ten years ago. i put this in the center of my home and it works well. i think i'll get rid of the others, now that i am clear that fans are not good to mix with EMF. thanks. patricia On Oct 12, 2012, at 3:53 AM, _paulpjc@aol.com_ (mailto:[hidden email]) wrote: > I find that the mains powered air purifiers can give off high levels of EMR > and dirty power so they negate the clean air benefit for me, unless you > can get a whole house system where the fan unit and electronics are well away > from the inhabited parts of the house and even then the unit should be > filtered for dirty power influx to your mains wiring > > puk ------------------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Links [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin
I have had that experience with the blackening of walls and furniture too - with an ionizer in my office back in the days when I was able to work
Steph ________________________________ From: Marc Martin <[hidden email]> To: [hidden email] Sent: Sunday, 14 October 2012, 20:30 Subject: Re: [eSens] Re: negative ion generators are not all equal On October 14, Elizabeth thode <[hidden email]> wrote: > Marc, You said: > > However, ion generators (even the kind without fans) > > caused a "prickly" ES sensation on my skin, so I > > abandoned using them altogether (plus they blackened > > my walls and furniture). > > Why/how did the ion generators blacken the walls? Lizzie All those particles that the negative ion generators remove from the air have to go somewhere -- unfortunately, they usually end up on a wall or a couch that's next to the generator. And that stuff's seemingly impossible to remove (we eventually through away the couch, repainted the walls, and banned negative ion generators from the house). Marc [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] |
That is true. It does blackening of the walls near by. --- In [hidden email], Stephanie Smith <reader41@...> wrote: > > I have had that experience with the blackening of walls and furniture too - with an ionizer in my office back in the days when I was able to work > > Steph > > > ________________________________ > From: Marc Martin <marc@...> > To: [hidden email] > Sent: Sunday, 14 October 2012, 20:30 > Subject: Re: [eSens] Re: negative ion generators are not all equal > > > Â > On October 14, Elizabeth thode <lizt777@...> wrote: > > Marc, You said: > > > However, ion generators (even the kind without fans) > > > caused a "prickly" ES sensation on my skin, so I > > > abandoned using them altogether (plus they blackened > > > my walls and furniture). > > > > Why/how did the ion generators blacken the walls? Lizzie > > All those particles that the negative ion generators remove > from the air have to go somewhere -- unfortunately, they > usually end up on a wall or a couch that's next to the > generator. And that stuff's seemingly impossible to > remove (we eventually through away the couch, repainted > the walls, and banned negative ion generators from the > house). > > Marc > > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] > |
Free forum by Nabble | Edit this page |